Wyndham Garden Broadway Fifth Customer Reviews Avg Rating :
AVERAGE Hotel Service Rating : AVERAGE Hotel Condition Rating :
AVERAGE Room Comfort Rating : AVERAGE Room Cleanliness Rating :
Guest Review: 1 Posted Date: 2012-04-21
Overall Rating Hotel Service    
Hotel Condition Room Comfort    
Room Cleanliness
Great for access to Chelsea and mid-town. One-half block walk to the east for Eataly, an excellent trattoria, but pricey. Great cappuccino, though, at a great price. One-half block to the west for Starbucks. Granduca di Sicilia, an excellent Sicilan restaurant, directly across the street. Great hotel staff too. It opened 4 days before we ate there,  so service was a little tentative. Probably worked out all the kinks by now. Great, great food. And that's from a Sicilian!
Guest Review: 2 Posted Date: 2012-04-17
Overall Rating Hotel Service    
Hotel Condition Room Comfort    
Room Cleanliness
As noted above the hotel is small our room barely fit the two double beds and bathroom was very small; but all very clean. Good news is that the restaurant attached has a great bar and across the street a great restaurant just opened.
Guest Review: 3 Posted Date: 2012-04-12
Overall Rating Hotel Service    
Hotel Condition Room Comfort    
Room Cleanliness
Enjoyed our stay at the hotel. The room was clean and comfortable.We enjoyed dinner at the restaurant San Marco one night. We had cocktails at the bar every night before turning in for the night. We would definitely recommend.
Guest Review: 4 Posted Date: 2012-04-05
Overall Rating Hotel Service    
Hotel Condition Room Comfort    
Room Cleanliness
Yes the size was small, but the bed quite comfortable. Bathroom was left wanting the most, poor shower design. But, overall, a real value for the location.
Guest Review: 5 by Urbi S of Sacrament Posted Date: 2012-04-04
Overall Rating Hotel Service    
Hotel Condition Room Comfort    
Room Cleanliness
I must first say I really enjoyed my visit to NYC. This hotel provided excellent customer service even allowing me to do an earlier check in. They were very accommodating and friendly. The room was a little small but overall it was clean. I definitely recommend this hotel.
Guest Review: 6 by Camille O of Michigan Posted Date: 2012-04-04
Overall Rating Hotel Service    
Hotel Condition Room Comfort    
Room Cleanliness
We spent 5 nights at the hotel. Staff were friendly and helpful. Room was clean and comfortable. Size was small as most NY hotel rooms are but it was adequate for 2 people. Maintenance staff was responsive and fixed a loose make-up mirror the same day I reported it. The location of the hotel (24th street between 6th Ave and Broadway) was great with  easy access to two subway lines that we took to go uptown to museums and central park, downtown to the Village and Soho, and to Brooklyn where we have relatives. It is also walking distance to the Highline park on the west side and very close to Madison Square park and the Garden on the east. Overall we were very pleased with the hotel and consider it a good value. We are likely to stay there again next time we are in NYC.
Guest Review: 7 by Beata L of Chicago, IL Posted Date: 2012-03-28
Overall Rating Hotel Service    
Hotel Condition Room Comfort    
Room Cleanliness
I will definitely stay here again. The room was nice and quiet, and had a large bathroom. The staff was incredibly friendly and helpful.
Guest Review: 8 by Eric W of Cary, NC Posted Date: 2012-03-22
Overall Rating Hotel Service    
Hotel Condition Room Comfort    
Room Cleanliness
Nice clean hotel with very friendly staff. I do a ton of traveling and staff and cleanliness make the hotel for me - and this was great.
Guest Review: 9 by YASSINE YC of Rbat, Morocc Posted Date: 2012-02-28
Overall Rating Hotel Service    
Hotel Condition Room Comfort    
Room Cleanliness
We were first time in New York, and we chose this hotel on the internet. In défintif we are not disappointed. The location is just excellent, between 5th and 6th Avenue, close to everything by foot, bus, metro, Eataly. The hotel is clean, the staff is very nice. The beds are big enough and sweet. Nothing to add. We will return.
Guest Review: 10 Posted Date: 2012-02-23
Overall Rating Hotel Service    
Hotel Condition Room Comfort    
Room Cleanliness
As nearly everyone notes, small rooms are to be expected in NYC and that is really the only drawback to this hotel. The front desk staff is excellent, with the possible exception of the concierge (which is fine, but not excellent) and which I am not entirely sure isn't some independent operation.